Unwarn request

[TommyK195 23]

Template

My In-Game name: GC ARC Captain Tommy

STEAMID: (http://steamidfinder.com) STEAM_0:0:174374752

Steam Name: TommyK195

What is the reason for your Warn: Supposedly ARDM

Name of the staff member who warned you: Shumacher

Why do I believe that I should be unwarned: Last week in EC room, i shot twice at someone as a commando droid with 2.5k HP, with no intention to kill anybody, hence why i stopped shooting after 2 bullets and I got warned which I think is slightly unreasonable considering what happened in the EC room about an hour ago from when this was posted. In EC room, 501st were using thermal detonators and committing Mass RDM, yet seeming as if they are allowed to do that because they only (barely) got a verbal warning for killing a many people which was seen in the logs and by many people who were already in the EC room and didn't die. I'm sure someone has it clipped and will link it underneath.
 

[Victor 210]

+1

 

Tommy had no intention of killing another EC, Yes i know that rules still apply to EC room but still, if he had intention to kill he would have shot more than 2 times.

[Kobi 56]

+1 
 Tommy wouldn't try to RDM in EC room and i have seen people RDM in EC room and got nothing

[Larry_P 50]

+1

I think perhaps a verbal warning would have been a better solution, especially if he only shot twice.

If he killed him or brought him very close to death then I guess it would be different

[Bean 80]

+1

Its a bit overkill, he only shot someone twice in the EC room. I understand this is done to try and prevent people killing each other in the EC room but at least give him a verbal warning.

[Nathan 72]

+1 

I dont think I have ever seen an event where ECs dont shoot each other in the EC Room Kinda stupid

[Torbjørn 11]

So because you didn't have intention to kill someone, you think you don't deserve to be warned for intentionally breaking the rules and shooting someone? I really don't see the logic there. You still commited RDM, by attacking someone else, you just didn't kill them therefore you only got warned for ARDM.

Fair enough you think that the 501st should get punished as well if they were throwing detonators and killing people. But that doesn't resolve you of your actions. If you see someone breaking the rules in the EC room, call staff or inform the event planner.

[Bansheey 304]

+1

Bean explained it perfectly, you dont warn for that in the EC room in my opinion otherwise alot of people would get warned for ARDM

[TommyK195 23]

5 hours ago, Torbjørn said:

If you see someone breaking the rules in the EC room, call staff or inform the event planner.

and that's what i did, and the staff member who answered my claim did nothing. That gives me no other choice than to believe that ARDM is more severe than MRDM. Not saying my actions weren't wrong, it's just that i'd expect other people to receive the same treatment and get warned.

[Blaster 50]

I don't know,the enforcement of OOC rules in staff room was always poor. While I agree that you should not have acted that way, a verbal warning to stop would be enough to stop it. As for the MRDM claim, no idea wasn't on at the time and staff should have noticed it especially the EP holding you there. Also if you really only shot him twice without actually having the goal of killing him, it shouldn't be much of a problem to remove the warn and leave it there. Keep in mind this is my opinion I was not present at the time.

[Mort 76]

This is just my opinion, but first we need to understand what RDM means, it stands for Random Death Match, ARDM therefore means attempted random death match, so if you did not had intentions to attempt to create a random death match with another player and you just shot him twice without that intent, then the warn should be removed, just my op tho.

Edited September 6, 2020 by Mort
added a word that was missing

[Puggo 55]

On 9/5/2020 at 1:02 PM, Torbjørn said:

So because you didn't have intention to kill someone, you think you don't deserve to be warned for intentionally breaking the rules and shooting someone? I really don't see the logic there. You still commited RDM, by attacking someone else, you just didn't kill them therefore you only got warned for ARDM.

Fair enough you think that the 501st should get punished as well if they were throwing detonators and killing people. But that doesn't resolve you of your actions. If you see someone breaking the rules in the EC room, call staff or inform the event planner.

Torbjorn summed it perfectly.