JoshNK64

If this is roughly how the scenario went, I don't believe it should've been a ban and let alone a warning, a verbal at most. This seems like a friendly interaction between 2 friends which has been misinterpreted as advertising. I feel like the staff member should've at least brought him to a staff room and if he truly did believe it was advertising, mute them before doing so as then they can no longer advertise for the time being while explaining themselves. +1

+1

This honestly seems like he was asking a few friends about his new server and wanted to see if people were interested in trying it out
Since Werewolf doesn't offer any World War 2 Servers (NRP excluded) I don't think this guy should be Perma banned.

The offering of an admin position is the only part were I am going That might be player pulling - But then he goes on to say the server is far from completion. He might have just wanted some trusted people to start up the server.

Ban him for 1 week as a warning/Acknowledgement to what he did but I do feel the Perma was harsh.

If more evidence of player pulling comes to light then the Perma is valid