Donny

+1 Matured a lot from when he was first on the server and I know he really wants it. Archer used to be real pain in the arse when he first joined CE but I believe Zeus and Toon gave him his telling off and he’s been near perfect since. He’s a good lad with a lot of potential and I can see him succeeding if given the opportunity.

+1 Great activity, great guy I’ve had great respect for him when I was in CE and this guy seems to thrive in every role he’s given.

+1 this guy spends too much time on GMOD. Can be strict but also knows how to have fun. Out of everyone I’d like to see Mojave as a battalion member I really believe he’d thrive in the role.

-1 Just use the DC-15s man.

+1 As a new 212th ET it’s kinda poop until you get to SO.

+1 Archer has gone above and beyond recently and has even become CE temp EXO in his time between apps. One of the most mature people for his age on the server and would be great if given the chance.

+1 Really sound guy, was one of the best CT SO’s out there and really deserves a chance

+1 I like the idea of specialisation would definitely add something more, and would in add to events on top of that as well with different squads having goals allowing hierarchy’s to be a bit more tactical. A few downsides pie has mentioned and it would probably be a rough transition to implement but why not in all honesty. I can’t see this happening any time soon but would love to see it.

-1 some answers are very short and sometimes wrong. Everything Feymous has said is true and in my opinion it is a subpar application. I think with a bit of playtime on the server when it comes out would definitely help this application out but good luck to you anyway!

Neutral Whilst it was a genuine mistake the rules were broken I can understand why you’d want it removed but at the end of the day it is only a warn. Don’t get too worried about it pretty sure you’re not the kind of guy to go around breaking loads more so I don’t think it will effect you negatively in the future.

+1 This application is a great improvement on the previous one, I believe his old behaviour is gone and it’s worth giving him an opportunity

+1 Ridiculously active in Jedi with trainings, competent. Can be strict and stern when needed, really stepped up when CG were in a bad space and would be a great battalion member.

I’ll start by saying Kato as a person I really like you and I think you’re more than capable as a player to do well as an EP The idea of cutting off comma so the CIS reinforcements can’t come is a good idea. The event plan is very detailed even down to where the EC’s will be positioned - very nice. Personally think Christophsis is a stinky map The super weapon part has been seen a lot before and people might be sick of it. Overall, +1 great guy and a good app

Neutral I do agree that there should be a better incentive to play EC and sometimes it is really annoying getting destroyed, this might not be the best approach but I think there should be a discussion about implementing some sort of system.

+1 really well thought out and in depth plan can tell you’ve put a lot of effort in to all of it, your rank shows your maturity and dedication.

+1 something fresh is needed this would be great can’t wait for Defcon gaming to come and chat shit

-1 unfortunately the plan does lack a lot of detail in regards to what is actually happening it would probably be best to have a few different actions happening in the event rather than blowing up GR and stealing data, flesh it out a bit.

-1 / Neutral The event is basic as Zeref said the main issue I have an issue with is that the miners turn infected just because. It has the potential to be a good event if there is some sort of reason for it happening and a bit more of a story rather than it just being miners have come for crystals, we’ve seen that hundreds of times. I personally don’t feel like you should be punished for putting a base attack on the app but I think the EP staff prefer it. You’re a very dedicated member of the server and I don’t think you’d have an issue mentality wise but the plan just lacks slightly hence the -1/Neutral

Neutral Your application is good and it is clear that you are very serious about the role. As many have said you are a little less known which is not the best for a Battalion app due to the nature of the role. With regards to your ban I believe you and Harland were able to come to an agreement over it so should not be as much as a prominent factor however it is the elephant in the room. Any way good luck for your application!

+1 new maps look great and would break up the monotony of the day to day server experience

-1 Nothing against you at all you’re actually a sound guy, problem is the application is lacking a fair bit. I’d probably suggest waiting until the server is out see how it plays and then decide if you want to apply again, this server is going to play a lot different to SWRP which is where I know you from. Good Luck anyway!

+1 I’ve only recently spoken to fusion and everytime he’s been sound. From my experience with him he’s got every quality needed to succeed in Battalion. Take a chance on him.

+1 one of the best CE colonels I’ve played with and is more than deserving of the chance, event plan is pretty pog too

+1 had a few dodgey moments when I’m CE with him but since progressing to SO he’s really matured and I don’t see why he can’t succeed

+1 Used Scaffolding and other such props in CE passive RPs before and have never had a problem with any staff. Knowing Shepherd and Fluffy I can say without a doubt it wasnt to abuse any rules and the warn should be removed.