Breatoking

-1 For context, Storm outpost is only used 33.3% of the time seeming as we rotate between 3 other base maps (Not including Anaxes or Rishi) and those other two maps are: Venator Extensive and Titan base. Now we usually go to Storm because its a simple map and eays to use, aswell allows scavanges to do more where Titan and Venator Extensive restricts it greatly, along with that the Jedi temples on them are quite shit aswell. Other base maps have been suggested, including better Storm maps, but SMT have denied them on my occasions due to either the size of the map memory wise, or are just not very well optimised. I understand why you could think it is horrible, however Storm does have a Lower hanger which can be used, aswell as an entire outside, and coming from a Battalion, we would never deny someone who wants to do a training outside of MB. Good luck Beast, however this wont be changed anytime soon. -Connor/Breatoking

Neutral / -1 Firstly, your event in terms of effort is amazing. Very detailed in terms of what everyone needs to do and aalso the Jedi event is rather good. I also like how you have set up different scenarios incase regiments can not do certain things, such as if RC can not turn the bridge on. This adds another level of complexity to the event and makes the Battalion think of what he needs to do, meaning better leading. I have two issues. Firstly the map. Ryloth is a horrible map and for this idea to work, it will require a complex dupe to make it last atleast 35 minutes without a last stand, aswell as this it requires a great amount of certain regiments and if they are not online, it could ruin the flow of the event. Aswell as this, there was an issue a few weeks ago with you about to resign. Though you didnt, you flipped a coin and it doesnt put me in a good place to say "Yes" when you could easily do the same as an EP. I understand Doot can be.... Well him, but the same will happen in EP, with people saying your event was bad and leaving bad feedback, and I dont want you to leave because of someone not agreeing. Good luck Berlin, -Connor/Breatoking

-1 Personally I have no issue with you and I congratulate you on coming back and trying to rank up and atone partly for what you did. Aswell as that you did admit that you did do something wrong and you didnt try and deny that it was a valid ban, however I believe the time is to short for me to agree in anyway to unban you. It has been less than a month since you were banned and we hardly ever perminantly ban people who are not bots or trying to promote a server. Along with this you mass pinged atleast 6 regiments countless times and though it was all to be "Funny" I can only believe that you will do the same thing again once you grow bored. I believe that if you reach the rank of Major, I would be comforable with you coming back, afterall it would show your dedication to the server once more and it would mean you have more to lose in terms of friendships and your time. Though it seems harsh to not unban you, it is meant to be a punishment, and it will remind you to never do something like that again. Again, I do not mean to come off as harsh, but I do believe Corporal is a rank which many can reach within a matter of days so it doesnt show to much commitment just yet. Good luck Pending, -Connor/Breatoking

Denied Battalion Command and Admiralty have reviewed your application with far greater consideration than many other candidates and we have decided to deny you on this occasion. Our main points stem from your hot headedness during situations which don't require it. It comes across as childish and not representing Battalion's standards. Along with this, we have been given a video of you wanting to backstab a member of Battalion Command a few months ago, and though it never went through due to you being stopped, it shows that you are willing to perform something so dirty. Battalion has become more strict on any sort of backstabbing threats, and accepting you would go against our stance to stop it entirely in Battalion. You may re-apply in 2 weeks, however you will not be accepted until we see some meaningful and lasting change to your behaviour to others around you. Note: The video in question is not becoming public, however it was damning enough to almost lead to a demotion of both himself and a member of Battalion.

Neutral Personally I think the story is rather enjoyable and though it isnt anything new, it is something that isnt done often and shows the republic in a good light, rather then just killing people. They have a goal and they have to stick to it. Along with this, some real thought has been put into what every regiment will do and ontop of that there is a clear amount of ECs put and how much HP they will have each. My issues come from no Jedi event being put down in any sort of capacity. EPs need to be able to do both Jedi and Clone events and have them at the same quality. Ontop of that Kashyyk needs a good dupe for it to work well, otherwise people are running around in a rather predictable way. Aswell you could be more clear with all the ECs you will be using e.g stating the different B1s you will use for instance Enforcers, Assult and others. Good luck Flash (Joel), -Connor/Breatoking

+1 First off I would have no issue with you having ULX. Coming from a guy who played on Aurora Gaming and enjoyed it, I know the staff over there werent just given power just because. Aswell the event idea is very good and well thought out. Ontop of this there is a good diagram showing what people are meant to do which shows more thought then many other people would and ontop of that there is a very nice diverse EC line up. There are some smallish issues I see. First off the Jedi event seems to be taking a back seat in this. Its a nice idea, however I feel like it needs to be expanded more and made more impactful and fun for the Jedi. Ontop of that you didnt state how many ECs you will be using. A good rule of thumb is get atleast 9-10 ECs so keep that in mind. Good luck Melon, -Connor/Breatoking

-1 Usually I would start off with the good stuff, but... well... You didnt use the template in the correct place which should of been your first thing to do, and its just incompitence seeming as everyone else can do it. Also you didnt say how many ECs you will have and ontop of that the HPs are the same? They should be different and also have more of a difference between ECs. Have atleast 3 OR MORE types of ECs. Also as an EP you need to be able to do Jedi events, but I dont see one and there isnt even a segment for it. Overall it just feels like no effort went into the event and I have seen EPs who have 5 minutes to come up with an idea, make better choices then this. Also dont advertise your app on someone elses. I mean its more attention seeking than an ex Force Master -Connor/Breatoking

-1 I may commend you on making an application and putting some effort into it. Afterall the event idea itself isnt too bad as a basis for something else, however its quite basic. My issues are numerous, but lets go over the big ones. First the event is very basic, and Corrusant Below is a hard map to get events right and as far as I can tell, there wont be a dupe for it, making it hard to find the action and boring to play if I am playing "guess where the enemy is." Along with this, you didnt give the amount of ECs you will be using. You just said what jobs and the HP, so in theory you could just have one of each and that wouldnt work. Along with this, the story is messy at best and I couldnt understand alot about it, also NO JEDI EVENT?! As an EP, you have to do both a good Jedi and clone events and with half of that not there, I cant agree to see you as an EP. -Connor/Breatoking

+1 / Neutral Event wise I like the idea behind it aswell as that the story side of it is really strong. It seems like a lot of thought has gone innto the idea and aswell as that the Jedi side doesnt lack and they both seem quite balanced in terms of effort. Aswell as that thee are clear pictures which makes it easier to understand what you want out of the event and what needs to happen. I have some small issues. Firstly the map and idea isnt something new or unique and I would rather have something different with the map or something different entirely. Aswell as that, there are not enough ECs to make the event go to 35 minutes and that comes from the fact that the Provience is only able to make events go for 20 minutes at max until it feels boring and dull with the same hallway pushes which cause a great deal of deaths. Aswell I have heard that you can fuck about in your regiment, and while a joke here and there isnt bad, I may be quite concerned in giving ULX to you under that reasoning. Good luck CryStar, -Connor/Breatoking

+1 Lets first go into the event. I think its wonderful and a great story clone wise. It truly screams out that you thought of an engagig and realistic story and ontop of that you have shown some clear pictures on what you would like to happen. Aswell as that Tatooine Hideout isnt used as much as it could be so this is a good thing. Ontop of that you are clearly trusted with MCC which is a rather high possition so I have no issue in trusting you with ULX powers. My issues come from the fact that Tatooine Hideout can be quite annoying inside of the corridors and could cause some serious issues in terms of timing. This could easily be fixed with a large dupe on the outside which leads into the bunker itself. Along with that the event characters you picked are quite lack luster. You could of included enforcers, assult droids and others. I must also say the Jedi event lacks alittle. Good Luck Mel, -Connor/Breatoking

+1 212th is a explosive regiment and though medic does limit combat, it doesnt restrict someone to be apart of the battle. Medics already suffer heavily from not having equipment, so having grendades may make it more desirable to be apart of it. -Connor/Breatoking

-1 Coming from the guy who manages all of Battalion, I would not trust them with so much power, that includes my Brigadiers. Its a large thing to be able to promote people on cooldown and if any person can pratically do it then it doesnt feel special at all aswell as having the possibility to be abused HEAVILY. Along with this, Battalion's job is to recommend people who are doing well and we believe they deserve a promote, only in some cases with Battalion promote someone and those cases are few and far between. Another issue I have is that you are trying to push something for us, without even speaking to us first. If you have a serious idea or improvement, speak to me or another member of Battalion Command because we will listen (That does not mean we will agree however) and this just feels like an idea YOU want rather then something any member of Battalion truly desires. -Connor/Breatoking

DeniedBattalion Command have looked into your case and we do not believe you are ready for the role of Battalion again. We are still unsure by your mental health and also see some issues with attitude and activity. We suggest you think heavily about yourself and the future you want

-1 Making any sort of Cyber Security threat isnt taken lightly, and this isnt just on Werwolf gaming. If you made any threat about trying to get IPs then you will be banned, regardless if you do or dont.. And sure, you didnt make a clear indication that you would preform a DDOS attack, however the most common attacks on an IP is a DDOS attack, so it is only clear to put it down to that seeming as its so simple and easy too do. Coming from a guy who does Cyber Security, its a pretty shit threat to make and I bet you cant even save a Word Document by yourself, let alone DDOS anyone or get anyones IP without a guy from India telling you how to do it on a Youtube Video. Glad to see you gone, -Connor/Breatoking

DeniedBattalion Command do not believe you are ready for the responsabilities Battalion bring and we think you need to grow more as a person before we think of you as anywhere close to what is expected. Keep working hard, and maybe one day you will join us

AcceptedSpeak to a member of Battalion Command to get your interview

PendingBattalion Command believe you are ready for Battaliom, however you are currently helping CG due a tough time and we think its better for you to stay until things are stable

DeniedBattalion Command do not believe it is right to take away from a regiment that is struggling heavily after a large resignation. Once CG is more more stable, then we can think about your application

Denied Battalion Command do not believe that you are ready for the role, seeming as you recently resigned due to mental health and with recent events in OOC. I suggest you reach the rank of 2nd LT before we seriously think of you as a real applicant

4 out of 33 members are medics. Even with CO+ 4 out of 14 members are medics, so saying that most of them are medics is not correct, and most 41st die to fight a sniper, even medics

Neutral The rules could be more clear and more could be introduced, I agree. However many of the rules are common sense and Tusken is just a very limited job in general due to who they are and how powerful the weapon is. It would need a change to the job, or just leave it as is.

-1 The sniper is a very powerful weapon already, and while it could have a small buff (A 25 DPS increase MAX) it is perfectly able to deal with many types of ECs. With your sniper argument, an EC sniper is usually on their own and there has to be a max of 5+ 41st so we can use one, so its quite balanced in terms of that. 41st should be able to communicate and be able to deal with a sniper without any issue. Besices ECs get fucked anyway by snipers, buffing them will make it even worse

-1 I do quite like the story behind the event, and I will say that a base attack isnt too bad if it has a story like this, however there is a great deal wrong. First off its very complex and if one thing goes wrong, the entire thing will fall apart, which isnt good for an event. Along with this, you are pratically telling the Battalion how to lead, which is a big red flag. Also the HP is FAR too high for the ECs. My suggestion is cut the HP by 1000 and have atleast 3-4 more ECs. For a base attack 6-8 ECs is a perfect number. - Connor/Breatoking

Neutral Honestly I thik the map is pretty sick and would be amazing just for the fact that it would be a breath of fresh air. Along with that, Storm is used so much, and having a better quality map would do wonders for trainings and exploring, including scav content. The main issue is the size. I think its like 500mb, which is pretty large in terms of GMOD standards and I am unsure if Lewis would take kindly to such a large file being shoved into the server. Along with this, we suggested this map in EP while ago, and nothing got done so I am unsure if it would get put in. -Connor/Breatoking

-1 Creativity is fine, but executing these ideas in the real world is the ONLY important thing. You have been EP before and though you had some good ideas, these ideas were never executed with any sort of care or skill and I am afraid this will happen again with this event idea. Along with this I dont think you have thought the event through. Rhen Var is a last stand map. Yes, dupes can make it longer, and better, but there is nothing like that I can see, along with this, it seems like a complete copy from what everyone else does, bar the last stand, meaning you wont hit 35 minutes. -Connor/Breatoking